Friday, January 1, 2021

The age of suburbia


"Mr. Covid has been the best city and regional planner Australia has ever had. The suburbs will shine and regions will grow. Maybe we should forget about big city infrastructure projects for a while and spend it on our future resilient communities where people look out for each other.”

That’s a note from late 2020 from a good friend of mine - a highly regarded town planner in Australia, who has led both city planning for large metro cities and worked across the globe, most lately in the Middle East. He’s no dill. The irony is – and he’s right – that it’s taken a global pandemic to shake ourselves out of what now seems like having been under a spell for a long time: the idea of centralised, high density urban cores, surrounded by dormitory suburbs from which workers would commute daily, preferably on high volume public transport, to their city based offices. Our subservience called for endless amounts of public money to be thrown at inner city altars, rewarding the increasingly privileged professional clergy who enjoyed commensurately rising real estate prices, while suburban areas languished.


But the lure of the emerald city was always an illusion. In early 2013 in “The demography of employment part one: a suburban economy,” I made the observation that none of the actual evidence supported this vision:

“We have collectively developed a fixation on our CBDs and inner-city areas as economic drivers of employment. While they are very significant in size, they are not dominant relative to the spatial distribution of jobs throughout metropolitan areas. If the evidence is clearly pointing to cities with employment overwhelmingly located in suburban locations, and points to this trend continuing, it is possible that a variety of public policy settings could need resetting given the realities of our urban environment. It is equally possible that opportunities for growth and development to meet market demand for employment lands in suburban locations haven’t yet been fully captured.”

By early 2015, in “Is it time for suburban renewal?” I wrote: there seem now to be no shortage of publicly funded initiatives focused on delivering a better quality of urban existence within a five kilometre ring of the CBD, and too few focused on the hard and soft infrastructure deficits that our suburban areas are still living with.

However, no end of evidence or public debate was sufficient to wrest the planning orthodoxy from the centralised vision of the inner urban economy and its elites living, working and playing within a mystical 5 kilometre ring of a CBD temple.

Even in the face of obvious policy failure – rising congestion, chronic infrastructure lags and falling quality of life – faith in the religion of centralisation was not shaken. A 2018 ABC News investigation into overcrowding and infrastructure inadequacies in Sydney and Melbourne prompted the Planning Institute of Australia to respond with the suggestion that what was needed to fix the problems of centralisation and density was in fact more centralisation and density: “We want Tokyos, Parises, and New Yorks – and we can do that by planning well.” The fact that this policy prescription was unelectable given its electoral poison, was clearly irrelevant to PIA at the time.

But as my friend has since wryly observed, a virus has changed all of that. Property industry leaders who once worshipped at the altar of centralisation have sniffed the winds and seen hope of new salvation in the suburbs. Fund managers are predicting a significant fall in demand for CBD offices as workers adopt more amenable work-life practices – working from home or from suburban hubs. The chief of publicly listed developer Stockland – Mark Steinert – is now publicly predicting a shift of the entire metropolitan economy away from CBDs to more suburban locations. Such comments would have been heresy only just 12 months ago and no doubt been savaged by Stockland’s investors. They now reflect conventional wisdom.

The evidence globally is flooding in: high density urban cores are finding economic demand seep into suburban homes or suburban work hubs. There has been an exodus of workers and their employers from centralised, expensive cores. Once prized New York real estate is boarded up, tenants gone. Manhattan offices are being touted as possible residential conversions.

Elon Musk has declared he is moving to Texas, while Tech giants Oracle and Hewlett Packard have similarly set up shop in more affordable, more amenable, more liveable cities.  Fast growing US city economies are no longer poster-children cities like NYC or San Francisco or LA, but mid-scale cities like Austin Texas, Nashville Tennessee, or Phoenix, Arizona. The move is on. Remarkably, for the first time in 170 years, California has actually lost population.  

Even the Emerald Isle – Ireland – has seen Covid-induced changes to work lead to public policy responses in support of remote working. "COVID-19 has brought a change in terms of the way we work and remote working - or connected working, as I call it - is now a reality,” said Irish Minister Social Protection Minister Heather Humphreys.  "It was an aspiration only a year ago, and now it's a fact of a life - and it's a good thing".

Here at home, the evidence is also piling up. Regional economic growth seems to be getting an adrenaline boost from Covid, or more correctly our policy makers’ response to it - exhausted by lockdowns, the lure of a less dense environment is proving hard to resist for many. Figures from the Regional Australia Institute show that by late 2019, capitals were shedding jobs while regions were gaining them.

Only the most fervent centralist must now acknowledge that the age of centralisation has come to end. Indeed, as much was observed to be happening pre-Covid by the respected Brookings Institute in early 2019. The virus has just accelerated what was already underway.

Where does this leave the anti-suburban elites - the likes of Elizabeth Farrelly who infamously declared: “The suburbs are about boredom, and obviously some people like being bored and plain and predictable, I'm happy for them … even if their suburbs are destroying the world”?

Hopefully, it leaves them without a worshipping congregation anymore. Hopefully it means the suburbs and regions will no longer be regarded with disdain as second or even third rate living or working choices. Hopefully it also means we will see decades long obsessions with inner cities turn to more balanced views of where policy and infrastructure priorities should fall. 

 

We are at the dawning of an age of suburbia – where regional and suburban economic needs can respectfully and rightfully claim equal status with those of the inner city. Policy makers would be wise not to resist this change but instead to embrace and support it.

 

PS: Yes, “The age of suburbia” is a nod to the flower power song of hope from 1969 by The Fifth Dimension - “The Age of Aquarius.” You can get all groovy and sing along to the lyrics “Harmony and understanding, Sympathy and trust abounding, No more falsehoods or derisions, Golden living dreams of visions” … and watch the clip here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kjxSCAalsBE

 

Let the sunshine in!

25 comments:

  1. You should now read Elizabeth Farrelly's piece - from a somewhat different perspective - in the SMH this morning. Are we seeing a meeting of once polarised minds? However, despite the spruiking, I suspect reports of the death of the city have been grossly exaggerated!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Quite agree Bill ... the city centre won't die but at the same time, it's a good opportunity to share the love more widely?

      Delete
  2. With the internet replacing the CBD for agglomeration, the decentralisation wave can become extreme...why stop at traditional suburbia? How about building new villages, from the ground up, anywhere in the world and in remarkably beautiful locations?

    And basing the new developments on new technology (think: driverless golfcarts as opposed to big roads and noisy cars), and selling them to a global market, online, off the plan using VR headsets for accurate simulations. Why not? It's easy.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WPQhZWcv5TY

    ReplyDelete
  3. Well said Ross. We need alternative thinking about our city densities, city form, city v regional infrastructures and the building of more resilient communities. Of course cities won't die but our preoccupation with the bigger and bigger city needs rethinking. In June the NSW Planning Department announced that Sydney needs one million homes by 2041. Why? Because the past recent trend say so. This is not a planning decision. Trends are not destiny. The "trend" then becomes the justification for big infrastructure expenditure, mindless high density and continued sprawl. The Farrelly article yesterday railed against poorly executed high density development in Sydney and the long term future of that. Let's not mention the quality of many high rise environments in Brisbane. There is a meeting of minds here. We need much better planning thought and execution for our cities and regions.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Peter! Look forward to an article from you!

      Delete
  4. Great read Ross. Town planners have always been behind the timed.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Digitalproducts provides Advanced Digital Marketing Course Vadodara, India with live projects on ✔️SEO ✔️SEM ✔️SMM ✔️SMO and many more. 100% Placement Support, 10+ Certifications.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Aasan Kitne Prakar ke Hote Hain-Yoga is the best exercise for our body which helps us to be physically and mentally healthy. Yoga keeps our body healthy both inside and outside. Yogasan Ke Naam

    ReplyDelete
  7. SEO Company in Mumbai- SEO Company in Mumbai- Crawl My Line is one of the most esteemed and reliable best SEO company in Mumbai, India which offers SEO services to clients from different sectors.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Article Submission Sites In India - Crawl your link is a paid guest posting in india started in 2019. Content sharing website of 2021 and we have 2500 + SEO specialist which have registered already. Publish your stories & guest post now to crawl your link now

    ReplyDelete
  9. "Very Nice,I liked your blog Please do check our thank you cardsOnline
    "

    ReplyDelete
  10. Nice article ... really great informative article... check chocolate packaging

    ReplyDelete
  11. A very good and informative article…Check <a href=" https://www.vyakhyaa.com/products/herbal-hair-oil-100ml-3-38-fl-oz/”>herbal hair oil </a>

    ReplyDelete
  12. Check https://www.letscurlup.com/blogs/haircareblog/the-art-of-balancing-protein-and-moisture to know more about the art of balancing protein and moisture.

    ReplyDelete
  13. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  14. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  15. If you do not know how to choose the required input on Roku, let me suggest an article titled, How to select go.roku/selectinput Read the post a few days back. The instructions are clear and I could complete the device setup easily. If you are new to the Roku platform, spend your free time reading the article

    ReplyDelete
  16. Nice article!!
    really great informative article.
    We Anotherlight Provide Drugs and addiction Therapy session in Mumbai. Another light is equipped with trauma-informed therapists who help you work towards breaking the addiction cycle.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Buy Face Serum Online in india It will help for your skin once you apply to your skin

    ReplyDelete
  18. Really informative tech content ! thanks for sharing !
    Buy Anti Pollution Face Wash, Anti Pollution Face Wash online at Best Price From Navah.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Dear author, Wow great post You Have Created For paid guest posting. Thanks For Posting Such Great Content And Thanks.

    ReplyDelete