Thursday, July 5, 2018

Why we need more ways to measure CBD health

Above: Brisbane in 1982 - then and now. 

The Property Council’s “Office Market Report” (OMR) has long served as a proxy for the market health of our CBDs. But the nature of CBDs has evolved and changed dramatically over time, and office markets alone are no longer the indicator of city centre economic vitality they once were. Here’s why it’s time to broaden the thinking. 

The collection of data for the Office Market Report dates back to the late 1970s or early 1980s, for what was then BOMA (the Building Owners and Managers Association) but which from 1996 became the Property Council of Australia. The OMR was central to BOMA’s industry interests then – given the focus early on was almost exclusively on the investment and management of CBD office buildings. The OMR provided a catalogue of CBD Office buildings, their lettable areas, quality grades, vacancies and future supply. This was essential for assessing the demand for space and tracking market changes. Excel macros are today vastly superior to the early pen and ink paper calculations, but the OMR methodology and metrics remain largely the same since then. 

In those days, CBDs were primarily for business (the ‘B’ in CBD) and that business was conducted almost exclusively in various office towers. People flooded into work in the mornings and vacated in the afternoons. After hours and on weekends, CBDs were ghost towns. The idea of going to the city for a weeknight restaurant meal was almost laughable. The idea of shopping or entertainment in the city was equally limited in appeal.

Consider Brisbane in 1980. There was no Queen Street Mall (its first stage opened in 1982). The Myer Centre didn’t open until 1988. There was an old McDonnel & East Department Store in George Street but that was about it for retailing. There were almost no restaurants, with a couple of notable exceptions (anyone remember Milanos?) mainly focused on the business lunch trade. They mostly did not open for dinner. The Sofitel Hotel (which opened as a Sheraton) above Central Station didn’t open until the late 1980s, as did the Hilton (opening 1987). Prior to this, we had Lennons (now Next Hotel) and the Crest (now Mercure) and that was about it. The city in this era was all about office buildings and the office workers in them. Studying demand for office space was a suitable proxy for the health of the CBD economy because there wasn’t much else to it.




Above: A lot has changed since the 1980s. Maybe our measures of CBD health need to change too? Pictured is a photo titled "At the pub, Brisbane 1982" by photographer Rennie Ellis. 

How things have changed. In addition to a raft of new office buildings which have doubled the CBD office space stock since then, there have been even more significant changes to the composition of what makes the CBD tick. The Queen Street Mall alone now counts 7 shopping centres and over 40,000 square metres of retail space. In addition, new retail precincts are springing up along spines of the CBD. There are multiple new and recent hotels, adding nearly 2,500 rooms in the 2014-16 period along, with nearly 3,000 more to 2020 and roughly the same again predicted beyond 2020. Brisbane’s CBD and inner city accommodation industry sells more room nights than the Gold Coast. There’s also been an explosion of restaurants, cafes, bistros and eateries, there have been new cinemas and entertainment venues and a raft of luxury apartments added to the CBD as well. 

By now, the CBD was only partly for office workers; it was also a hive of activity for travellers, shopping, dining and recreational pursuits. On weekends when most of the office buildings are empty, the city can still be alive with activity. 

Now think about the new projects currently proposed for the CBD – many of which will further add to the variety of economic activity taking place in the city centre. Office projects, while still important, do not dominate.  

The $3.6 billion Queens Wharf project alone will add 1,000 hotel rooms across five hotels, 2,000 new apartments, a Casino, and multiple retail and dining options. Brisbane Quarter has recently added the W Hotel and will soon add a new residential tower, an office tower and extensive retail space. AEG Ogden’s Brisbane Live is a $2 billion entertainment focused proposal for the Roma Street Railyards which includes redevelopment of the Brisbane Transit Centre. The Howard Smith Wharves redevelopment will add a new 165 room Art Series Hotel, a range of dining, retail and tourism related attractions, meeting rooms and extensive public domain space. And Dexus’ proposal for a redevelopment of the Waterfront Precinct proposes two new towers with a combined 175,000 square metres – where possible uses are hotel and residential along with office space – plus up to 10,000 square metres of new dining and retail space. 

The point is that increasingly our CBDs are diversifying. Relying on an office market index now provides insight into only one aspect of the market. What is potentially needed is a new dashboard of indices to help shed light on the overall vitality and economic performance of a city centre. 

That dashboard would continue to include office market metrics, but in addition it would be good to measure other increasingly important parts of the city centre economy. Logically, such a dashboard would also include measures of hotel performance (occupancies, room rates and future supply), retail performance (vacancies, rents and turnovers), commuter traffic numbers (which should be readily available in real time via key transport corridors and public transport stations), performance of restaurant and catering establishments, and performance of the residential apartment market (vacancies, rentals and sales prices along with new supply). 

Not only do these uses contribute substantially to CBD employment and economic activity, they are also increasingly the focus of considerable public and private investment. There are compelling public policy and private industry reasons why a broader assessment of CBD performance is now timely. Those founding members of BOMA who were once focused on investment in CBD office buildings have evolved over time into institutions and private developers/investors with interests across the spectrum of built form uses now increasingly evident in our CBDs. 

The OMR served us well for 40 years and while an ongoing focus on office markets will remain important, the extent of changes to our CBDs means it alone is no longer sufficient as a measure of city centre economic performance or future prospects. 

36 comments:

  1. Ross

    Good yarn

    The same can be said for also all Property Industry 'public' intel.

    What gets measured/shared is the easy stuff to count, but it isn't the stuff that should be monitored.

    Also when you measure the right things, and correctly, the picture/outlook is more often than not much bleaker than the promoted real estate 'spruik/strut'

    Sadly very few - in my experience - will pay the appropriate fees to get the real measures.

    The general MO is don't question the industry 'fake news', fingers crossed and hope for the best...

    ...and I think Australia's luck is running close to empty.

    PS And for mine - the list of new shinny things proposed for the Brisbane CBD will just hollow out other buildings/uses in the CBD/inner city - Brisbane hasn't got the economic grunt to support this stuff - all just 'bread and circuses' - fix the pot holes first, pay key workers better, we really don't need a new casino etc...well not until we fix the vital stuff

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Not wrong, Michael. But hasn't this always been the case of'self serving' property research. I did my masters research 20 years ago on one of the major reasons for the 'hollowing out' of the CBD, workplace functional change. The outcomes are visible today.

      Delete
    2. Antony - I'd be interested in seeing that research if you still have it?

      Delete
    3. I might have a hardcopy, Ross. I'll see what I can find.

      Delete
  2. As usual, Ross, to the bone ! ;-)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Excellent piece Ross. How could we make this type of measure happen? Is it something that the should stand alone from the PCA, say an annual health check presented at the BDA and possibly funded from BCC, the government architects office, Brisbane Marketing & interested corporate players. I would love to help if you thought it worth pursuing? Matt Miller

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Matt - many of the indices are already available... it would take some collation but not as big a task as it might seem (I suspect). Will drop you a note...

      Delete
  4. Ross Elliott's line of argument starts with what is called a "genetic fallacy". Specifically, Mr Elliott suggests that a little known report called the Office Market Report "has long served as a proxy for the market health of our CBDs". That the paper provides no material evidence to support this claim and that it attributes to the report the mysterious ability to diagnose the "market health" of a geographical area is a little puzzling . According to Almosawwi, 2014 [in An Illustrated Book of Bad Arguments] the use of genetic fallacy is often used by someone when that person is emotionally attached to an idea's origins. In any event I am only speculating why Mr Elliott would now be suggesting such a spaghetti bowl of unbalanced and narrow measures as is proposed for a new and improved "Market health" indicator for the CBD [e.g. hotel performance, retail performance,commuter traffic numbers, performance of restaurant and catering establishments, and performance of the residential apartment market]. Mr Elliott proposes that the new report could present "a new dashboard of indices to help shed light on the overall vitality and economic performance of a city centre". A dashboard works most effectively when you measure all the primary inputs and outputs and the operator is trained to know the optimal conditions for operating the system under review. Maybe some effort would be well placed to build a more balanced perspective of a city health. Otherwise, observers may think that the proposed dashboard was primarily designed to serve a narrow vested interest. Which is my recollection of one of the reasons the OMR was a little used report by those seriously interested in the market health of our city.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Infinite CBD’s is a best local medical store where you can buy CBD OIL online with free shipping.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Our cosmetic tattoo supplies give permanent makeup artists what they need to excel. We stock all the supplies needed for cosmetic tattoos here. Shop now.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Amazing Information. I read your post very carefully. It is very helpful information for me. Thanks for sharing with us.
    Are you looking for a Loan Company Near Me? If yes, then don't go anywhere. Here, Easy Loan Mart offers one of the leading loan services at zero interest rate along with more benefits. If you wish to apply for a loan, and you are not sure what is required to process the loan, you can contact our qualified experts through a toll-free number. Our professionals will guide your loan proposal or benefits.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thank you for posting such a great article. Keep it up mate.

    Nainital Bank Net Banking

    ReplyDelete
  9. The information in your article is excellent. Thank you for sharing it with us. Your insight is incredible, and it's great to find a site that gives the community a different perspective. We will tell you about our profile in such a situation. Also, you can use emoticons and create your own chats using the same information. Check out our profile fake whatsapp chat generator.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Gold Loan - Apply for Instant loan against gold jewellery with 1%* Interest Rate & Minimum Documentation! Why go for Personal or Business loans when you have the power of gold with you! Get a loan against your gold, in minutes!

    ReplyDelete
  11. Thanks for this informative blog
    Many customers are eager to learn what measures they should take to resolve the issue of How to Send Money Cash App To Google Pay. To fix these issues instantly, please contact our Cash App Customer Service, they will provide you with relevant solutions related to your issues.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Useful information This . thanks
    If you are looking for SUPER TET Recruitment 2022, then you must visit India's largest growing education platform, Spin On Education which provides the best entrance exam preparation material and counseling.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Very impressive post i appreciate you. thanks for sharing with us. If you are looking for all types of details regarding. SGPGI PDCC 2022 Then you must have a look at our website. You will get all the details including exam preparation, syllabus, exam date-sheet, cut-off, and other things in detail. For more information, visit our website.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Well I truly enjoyed reading it. This subject offered by you is very helpful and accurate. Also check out Brussels airlines cancellation policy cancel your flight as per your need, and apply for a ticket refund by dialing +1-844-673-0381. Passengers can cancel the flight up to 4 hours before the flight exists then they will be required to pay the cancelation fee.

    ReplyDelete
  15. GetZend, the leading online video training platform helps to achieve success in life without stress. Download the award-winning meditation app to reduce stress and get professional interactive training, life quotes, success quotes, motivational quotes by Zahra Karsan.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Corporate motivational speakers matches their content perfectly with your event objectives to deliver results.

    ReplyDelete
  17. GetZENd, an award-winning inspirational App, offers a suite of interactive tools that include online video training and help you stay on track with your life goals without compromising your life experience. Use GetZENd, a positive thoughts app to relax or change to a more effective state of mind quickly and easily.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Random Person Sent Me Money on Cash App: quick tips to handle it:
    Most often, cash app users have issues regarding Random Person Sent Me Money on Cash App. Therefore, what should be the tip that may help them handle the entire factors? A cash app is a digital platform that allows people to send and receive money with no delays. The requirements are the crucial aspect and users must know how to fulfill those at once.

    ReplyDelete
  19. The GetZENd app is free to download and includes free content to use. The GetZENd subscriptions unlock all meditation features as well as future releases while the user has an active subscription.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Amazing insight you have on this, it's nice to find a website that details so much information about different artists. Do you know how to test your APM? if not, then refer to the profile APM click test and find your clicking speed today.

    ReplyDelete
  21. CleanNet Cleaning is the professional House keeping and House Cleaning services in Kochi, Ernakulam. Our cleaning services for homes & offices includes deep cleaning, sanitization, disinfection services with experienced cleaners in Cochin, Kerala.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Bright House Cochin is a professional House Keeping and Cleaning Services provider that offers high quality domestic cleaning and office cleaning services in Kerala. 100% quality, fast and friendly cleaning services.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Diamond Watch Traders is one of the best luxury Watch Repair & Restoration service Shop in Dubai, UAE. Our services includes watch cleaning, watch restoration, glass replacement, bracelet adjustments etc.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Engineering and Medical Entrance Coaching in UAE, Resonances Top IIT JEE and NEET coaching in Dubai UAE. Sat classes in Dubai ,crash courses.

    ReplyDelete
  25. what is a general ledger in Quickbooks many reporting choices in Quickbooks, including effective reports for keeping track of finances and getting crucial information. Ledger General One such requirement for tracking transactions from all accounts, such as Cash, is Quickbooks Report

    ReplyDelete
  26. Hey There, I am Sofia Carter. If an HP Printer Not Printing Black, try these methods. Ensure that your devices are correctly connected to one another and that the network or cable you use to connect them is appropriate. Restarting your HP printer is another option. After completely shutting it off and unplugging the power cord, give it a few moments to cool. Further, turn on the printer after plugging the cord back in. Alternatively, updating or reinstalling the printer driver could be necessary to resolve this problem.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Nice post thanks for sharing such an informative post. We are leading the best quality Accounting Assignment Help for students with local academic writers. Getting the best Accounting Assignment Help to perform better in academics.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Hello, I am Alina John. I am a content writer. I write all about the Cash App problems. Are you looking for How to change cash app pin ? Then you are in the right place. Read My Blog.

    ReplyDelete
  29. Great article, very informative and well written. I must say that you are a master of your subject. Like you, I am also here to promote my WordPress Support company in the digital world. So if you have any queries or doubts related to WordPress, then contact us without any hesitation. We line in the USA and provide WordPress help worldwide.

    ReplyDelete