Thursday, August 2, 2018

How we lit the fuse on the population bomb


We’ve been here before – concerns about our capacity to house a large population are not new. But lately, hostility to rapid rates of population growth is gaining traction. There have been calls for a population enquiry and former PM Abbott has called for immigration (and hence population growth) to be slashed. He joins a chorus of other voices, from business to community groups. Voters are pushing back against growth and political leaders are feeling the pressure.


But these pressures are confined to mostly two cities: Melbourne and Sydney (and perhaps to a lesser extent Brisbane). There are other capitals and countless regional cities who covet growth but who find it eludes them. Instead, stupidly (it has to be said) we continue to cram accelerating population numbers – mostly driven by immigration – into a couple of urban centres. 

Melbourne was first settled by whites in 1835 and took 165 years to reach 2.5 million people (by the year 2000). Bernard Salt predicts the next 2.5 million will be added in just 21 years with the city reaching five million by 2021. He thinks it will sail past eight million by 2050. Sydney has a similar story.

According to the Productivity Commission’s 2016 Migrant Intake into Australia report, 86% of migrants settled in major capitals, compared with 65% of the Australian born population. More recent information suggests the trend has grown, with only 6% of recent migrants now settling in regions.

The Government has toyed with the idea of insisting that migrants settle regional areas where there are genuine labour shortages but there seems little determination to back the threats with action, which in itself could be difficult (and possibly illegal) to police.

Outsiders observing Australia’s handling of growth must be incredulous to learn that much of the concentration of growth has not occurred by accident, but is widely endorsed policy. Higher urban densities have since the late 1990s been at the core of urban development policy to handle population growth in the very cities now feeling the most resistance to growth. The benefits promised as a result of increased density were many and the public were assured that they would share in an improved quality of life as a result of these policies. Take this example from the 2013 Draft Metropolitan Strategy for Sydney to 2031:

“A home I can afford. Great transport connections. More jobs closer to where I live. Shorter commutes. The right type of home for my family. A park for the kids. Local schools, shops and hospitals. Livable neighbourhoods.”

And the result? For Sydney and Melbourne especially, housing affordability is as bad as the worst in the world with entire generations locked out of housing. Congestion is chronic. Private and public transport systems are under more pressure than ever. Commutes take longer and housing choice has been compromised. Is this livable? Talk about over promise and under deliver. If these promises had been borne out by the day to day experience of average Australians living in these cities, there wouldn’t be the push back politicians are feeling now.

Even more incredulous is that, confronted with the political challenge of an increasingly hostile public, some suggest (from the comfort of their high priced inner urban enclaves no doubt) that what’s needed is not change, but more of the same. The Planning Institute of Australia recently suggested as much, responding to a challenge from ABC interviewer Ellen Fanning on the 7.30 program that we are ill prepared to cope with “stuff(ing) another three and a half million people into Melbourne and Sydney both”.
The PIA responded that “We’ve got a great challenge to ensure that we don’t end with megacities like Lagos or Manila. We want Tokyos, Parises, and New Yorks – and we can do that by planning well.” (emphasis added).
Really? Tokyo, Paris and New York might be on our bucket list of cities to visit, but how many average Melbourne or Sydney residents would live in hope they’d one day see their own city turn into a version of Tokyo or New York? I can think of no public opinion poll where we Aussies have put up our hands to using Tokyo as a business model for urban development. Any politician suggesting as much would last a nano second before being turfed out.
It serves to illustrate how wide the disconnect has become between public policy makers and the wider community. The “we” word is used when the “I” pronoun is what’s really meant.
Maybe it’s time for a genuine reality check? I’ve always held the view Australia can readily support a larger population but in getting there, infrastructure standards need to keep up with growth, not continuously lag it. Housing and lifestyle choices don’t have to be further compromised to serve a model of urban development which is at odds with broader public opinion. The idea that much of this growth should continue to be concentrated in just a handful of cities already feeling considerable strain while other centres with infrastructure capacity and abundant, affordable housing find growth eluding them is plain crazy.
The answer I suspect is not in forcing people to settle cities and regions that are capable of absorbing growth but in making these cities and regions even more attractive as places to settle. Jobs, industry and economic growth lie at the centre of this. Positive economic attraction strategies, reduced tax or red tape burdens, abundant and low cost utilities (power, gas, water), ‘special economic zones’ – all are elements capable of attracting employers and industries, and with them jobs for workers and their families. And if regional employment was further supported by the type of place making and related infrastructure support more typically only on offer in the centres of major capital cities, there’s no reason at all that centres like Mackay, Armidale, Wagga Wagga, Orange, Casino, Bendigo and plenty of others can’t enjoy growth without the accompanying political pain.
Sadly, even this rather obvious policy option isn’t being explored. According to a recent report in the Sydney Morning Herald: “Inner-city centres on the east coast have amassed the greatest share of Australia's new public service jobs under the Coalition government as outer suburbs, bush towns and Canberra took cuts to their ranks of bureaucrats.” So we not only concentrate our population into a few centres but government jobs as well. This is hardly spreading the load or sharing the benefits.
Stopping growth by rapidly closing down immigration would be disastrous for industries which have come to rely on it but this is increasingly looking like it’s possible. But equally, persisting with our current approach will only further aggravate hostile electorates in the major cities, while electorates in centres with little growth could be equally cranky with governments for failing to produce growth where it’s wanted.  
The fuse on the population debate has been lit. And maybe we are the ones that lit it. 

34 comments:

  1. Spot on Ross. How can a country as large as Australia with such a small population have an housing affordability issue?
    And not even have a meaningful debate about how to address it.
    Regional jobs and relocation of government services will go a long way to resolving the issues. In southeast Queensland areas such as Toowoomba, Gympie, Bundaberg are all crying out for population, jobs and infrastructure spend.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Well said, Ross. Tokyo, New York and Paris? Get outta here. It would desiccate our Aussie souls in a heartbeat. A hideous form of torture - and it's almost a reality in Sydney already. It is truly unbelievable that this issue is not the hottest topic of national debate. Astounding that we have surrendered the Great Australian Icon of universal home ownership without demur, effectively. How can it have come to this? Our polity is bereft or not just imagination but intelligence that they cannot see the eventual backlash when the soporific wake up. It ain't gonna be pretty.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Which industries "would be disastrous for"?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Spot on again, Ross ... as usual ! Academic planners have a lot to answer for, they need to be more careful with what they wish for though I think that as with much academic research nowadays it is strongly influenced by the 'publish or perish' policies of those institutions.
    With much of manufacturing industries decimated through globalism and agriculture becoming dominated by 'commercial production' the vexing question is, how does one encourage and retain immigrants in the regions ?

    ReplyDelete
  5. Our assignment helpers have great writing skills and run a comprehensive assignment check to provide you with a custom online Assignment help.
    Assignment help online

    ReplyDelete
  6. I enjoy kinds very own post. It will be respectable to get a single narrative inside and outside of the core of this distinctive core specialized niche will likely be commonly knowledgeable.
    best online assignment help

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hope you will keep on offering good content like this more often. I feel more and more people should know about this. Also, I agree on most of the points you have made.
    Ikea dubai

    ReplyDelete
  8. I know this is one of the most meaningful information for me. And I'm animated reading your article. But it's a good thing, the website is perfect; the articles are great. Thanks for the tone of tangible and possible help.
    toyota organizational structure
    toyota supply chain management
    toyota corporate

    ReplyDelete
  9. I and my friends often read your posts and discuss on them. We get valuable information through your posts. Thanks a lot.
    java training institute in noida

    ReplyDelete
  10. Your post is very great.i read this post this is a very helpful. i will definitely go ahead and take advantage of this. You absolutely have wonderful stories.Cheers for sharing with us your blog. python training in noida

    ReplyDelete
  11. The blog written is extremely impressive, with a great topic. However, a bit more research could have strengthened it even further. You can explore the services as offered by livewebtutors.com, a premium academic writing services platform offering the best of Harvard Referencing Generator teamed with knowledge and experience.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Such a wonderful information blog post on this topic Allassignmentservices.com provides assignment service at affordable cost in a wide range of subject areas for all grade levels, we are already trusted by thousands of students who struggle to write their academic papers and also by those students who simply want MATLAB Programming Help to save their time and make life easy.

    ReplyDelete
  13. My Name is Abhay Kumar. I’m a Blogger living in India. I am a fan of technology, design, and writing. I’m also interested in programming and blog. I would like to share articles related to SEO, blogging tutorials, WordPress Tutorial, Make money online. You can read my blog.
    php training in gurgaon

    ReplyDelete
  14. Use Assignment Helper administrations in the event that you don't discover anything to form your scholarly paper or schoolwork. Now and again, you can't focus on your investigations in view of being occupied with numerous exercises and discover hard to compose your assignment.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Sometime, your printer may get offline or print jobs get stuck in the print queue and because of that you won’t print anything. In such situation, you need to avail HP Printer Troubleshooting guidelines from well-professional tech-savvy to deal with such a printing problem. When you contact to them via helpline number, the printing error issue that you encountered will surely be eradicated within a couple of second. If the call is not going through, then you can email us or text messages to get one-stop solution in hand.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Hi my name is Jimyyandrew. I am from technical team i have 2 year of expriance.If you face any problem for setting up hp printer you can visit on this link 123.hp.com/setup here you will find right steps for setting up hp printer.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Windstream login issues are common. You can fix them all on your own with a little guidance. This is why we bring to you this quick guide addressing all your concerns and queries regarding windstream email login issues at the snap of the fingers.

    ReplyDelete
  18. WPS (Wi-Fi Protected Setup) is a wireless network security standard which is purposely used for making direct connection between router and wireless devices faster and easier. When connecting your device to a router, it will ask for WPS PIN
    . So, before connecting the device to router, find out the PIN code first and then enter the same to securely establish connection and happily print wirelessly. If you have a WPS-enabled wireless router or access point that supports PIN mode, you can freely use Wi-Fi Protected Setup (WPS) PIN mode to connect your scanner to the network. Here is how to use WPS PIN Mode:
    • Open the input tray first
    • Press and hold the “Wi-Fi ON/OFF” button for a couple of second
    • Then after release the button when the light flashes blue
    • Afterward, enter the PIN Code on the wireless router or access point within two minutes.The device is now been connected to your router network.



    ReplyDelete
  19. 192.168.1.1 IP address is widely used as the address pointing to the network router for Internet Access that you have at home. It is one of a few most commonly used IP addresses that router makers assign to a router, 192.168.l.l is the most usual one though 10.0.0.1 or 192.168.0.1 are also among the well known ones. These are also called and defined as host addresses.
    What configuration is available at 192.168.1.1

    The 123.hp.com/setup is actually a website which is set up by HP technicians to help people set up their HP Printer by downloading the printer drivers and other software through this website. On this website you can find directions on how you can connect your HP Printer wirelessly, with help of USB cable and even things like how one can install a cartridge in the printer.

    ReplyDelete
  20. If you don’t have sufficient time to write your assignment, place order for assignment help services in Kuwait. Connect with professional academic writers using the services of assignment writing help even in your budget.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Is your Canon printer offline? Here’s how you can get it back online in a few simple ways. First of all, you should try to reconnect your printer to the wifi and then see if it is back online or not.
    If not, then hold the printer’s wifi switch till the lights start flickering. Once if constantly blinks blue, press the router’s WPS button. If this doesn’t help then you can restart the spooler services.
    You should also make sure that the canon printer has been set as default otherwise it might continue to show offline status even though it will be on and perfectly connected.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Use Finance assignment help to finish your finance or accounting papers without messing yourself. You will get assured solutions to your numerical questions within your defined date or time.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Check out the option of assignment help in New Zealand to buy the assistance of academic writing. Online Assignment Help connects you with professional writers so you can get requisite help for your submission.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Nice Post...
    What are easy methods to rectify HP printer not responding?
    HP printer is a well-known brand in all over the world. HP printer is specially known for its amazing printing features and advanced printing functions. It is fully loaded with wonderful printing features. On a regular basis, a lot of users are coming to choose it and using it for different printing purposes. Mostly both home and business users prefer it for the best printing services. I am also a home user and using HP printer from the last four years. I always feel a pleasing experience with my printing machine, when I work on it. My printing machine is very simple and best product in using, so almost all users look for it. Due to some unexpected reasons, My printing machine is not printing the documents. When I try to work on my printing machine, I am getting HP printer not responding issue. Really, it is a difficult task for me. I want to come out from this technical blunder as soon as possible. So I have used the expert’s help from www.hp.com/support, but I got nothing. My all efforts have gone wasted. I have checked all things about my printing machine. I am unable to guess wrong thing about my printing machine. Now, I want to hire the reliable, best and affordable technical support services for HP printer not responding error. I am looking for online technical help. So anyone can recommend the easy ways to resolve HP printer not responding error. Your suggestion would be highly admired.
    HP Support
    HP Printer Support
    hp.com/support
    support.hp.com

    ReplyDelete
  25. QB errors are often common as most of the users face them and they can be resolved on your own. But QuickBooks Error 15222 is different as this technical error happens while downloading a Payroll or QuickBooks Desktop Update. It is better if you reach out to the QB experts to resolve this issue. While downloading the latest update for QB Desktop or payroll service you are likely to face this issue. If you want to try to fix it on your own, you can try the solutions given below-
    • Install Digital Signature Certificate
    • Manual Software Update
    • Validate IE settings
    It is always advised not to go deep into the functionality and call the QB support team to help you in resolving the issue.

    ReplyDelete
  26. WPS PIN
    is a password (personal identification number) to connect your wireless printer with the WiFi network. Follow the steps given below to identify the WPS pin and set up your printer connection.
    6. Go to the control panel of Your HP printer
    7. Click on the wireless icon button.
    8. In the next step, click on the gear icon ‘settings’ option.
    9. After clicking on the Wifi protected setup, follow the instructions shown on your screen.
    10. In the next step you will see the WPS PIN on-screen.While following the above mentioned steps, reach out to our support team for any help

    ReplyDelete
  27. Dans le mode de vie d’aujourd’hui, il est très facile de récupérer des douleurs et d’autres problèmes liés à la colonne vertébrale. La raison étant que vous devez vous asseoir toute la journée devant votre ordinateur et qu'une chaise inconfortable ajoute plus de problèmes à votre vie. Bien que vous ne puissiez pas modifier votre travail et votre emploi du temps, vous pouvez faire quelque chose pour vous sauver de cette souffrance inutile. Oui! On parle de Fauteuils Contre Les Maux De Dos À Toulouse qui est fait en gardant à l'esprit les maux de dos. Ces chaises ont un support lombaire grâce auquel vous pouvez toutes les passer sans même vous sentir un peu fatigué ou une douleur dans la colonne vertébrale. Certaines des caractéristiques étonnantes de Fauteuils Contre Les Maux De Dos À Toulouse

    ReplyDelete
  28. PNJ Sharptech, one of India's quickest Responsive Web designing services provider. Our Low cost Web designing services team is fully equipped with the top set of skills, tools, and sources. With appealing graphics and accessible, complete user-friendly navigation our website designers team guarantees that your site not only brings just traffic but also engages and helps you to convert them to clients.

    Also Read: Top Reasons To Choose React Native for Mobile App Development

    ReplyDelete
  29. Epson printers are the popular printing devices, with the WorkForce series as the most applauded one amongst the users. However, in several instances, the users encounter an error when their Epson cannot communicate with the scanner. In such a case, your printer needs an immediate fix or an expert’s help. We are a team of engineers and printer technicians who can help you resolve the communication error in your printer.

    ReplyDelete
  30. The WordPress Live Chat is one of the superb techniques to direct questioning and answering. However, it might still wind up being a program that provides the greatest Return of Investment for one's business or personal blog. Probably what would be the trademark and benefits of adding live chat to your blog?

    ReplyDelete
  31. Many aspirants face different types of issues to deal with their essays and assignments. For them, writing assignment help services are the right option. When you hire teachers, you are safe because the mentors are skilled in this field. They know how to deal with critical essays and complete it within the timeframe. If you are looking for the best Assignment Help or you need the top assignment experts for your assignment, you can u can get all the support here. We have a team of dedicated and professional staff who can give you a fruitful solution and help you get good grades.

    ReplyDelete